Introduction
This article was written in connection with the webinar on directional preference and provides a structured framework to help clinicians interpret the scientific literature surrounding these concepts.
Directional Preference is a concept that has generated both enthusiasm and controversy within the musculoskeletal field for several decades. Much of the debate has focused on the effectiveness of treatments associated with the MDT McKenzie Method. However, a more fundamental question is often overlooked: does directional preference exist as a real clinical phenomenon, and how should we reason scientifically about it?
The purpose of this article is therefore not to settle the debate, but to provide a clear reasoning framework that clinicians can use when approaching the available evidence. By examining the phenomenon through several independent parameters — including reliability, validity, treatment effect modification, competing explanations, and biological plausibility — we can better understand how such clinical constructs emerge and evolve within scientific disciplines.
To support this reflection, a visual infographic summarizing this reasoning framework is also available.
📥 Download the infographic summary here: LINK
Directional Preference: From Clinical Observation to Scientific Construct
One hundred and forty-nine published articles on directional preference. One hundred and eleven different definitions. A field is divided between those who claim the phenomenon explains virtually every spinal presentation and those who cite a Cochrane review to dismiss the entire concept. The debate has been loud, long, and — from an epistemological standpoint — largely unproductive.
The core problem is not a lack of data. It is a lack of conceptual rigour on both sides of the argument. Studies are pooled across populations that were never subgrouped for directional preference, assessed by clinicians with heterogeneous training levels, using definitions that vary from one paper to the next. The 2023 Cochrane review concludes that the MDT McKenzie method is not effective for non-specific low back pain — but evaluating a treatment in a population where the relevant subgroup has not been identified is methodologically equivalent to assessing the efficacy of amoxicillin in “sick people” without distinguishing bacterial from viral infection. The error is conceptual before it is statistical.
This presentation takes a different approach. Rather than adding another layer to an already polarised literature debate, we ask a more fundamental question: does directional preference actually exist as a clinical phenomenon? And more importantly — what is the correct reasoning framework for answering that question?
The starting point is a raw clinical observation. A patient presents with leg pain radiating to the foot. After a few minutes of repeated extension loading, the pain centralises, retreats proximally, and abolishes. The response is rapid, reversible, and directionally specific — reproducible across repeated testing, in the same direction, in the same patient. It is not an antalgic position. It is not a non-specific pain modulation response. It is a surprising fact that demands an explanation.
Science — understood as the best available method for approximating reality while minimising individual observer bias — requires more than a binary answer. Faced with a surprising clinical fact, the rational approach is to identify the hypothesis that best explains it, and to test that hypothesis against its competitors.
We propose to evaluate directional preference across five independent parameters. First, reliability: is the sign reproducible across independent examiners, under ecological conditions, with an appropriate level of training? Available data support a positive answer — provided these two conditions are met, which the majority of published studies fail to ensure. Second, validity: is the sign linked to a real biological event or process? Studies by Donelson, Young and Laslett, and our own data published in 2025, demonstrate a strong correlation with controlled lumbar discography, with a positive likelihood ratio of 7.65. This is not a trivial association. Third, treatment effect modification: if directional preference is real, it should predict a differential response to treatment depending on whether it is present or absent. The Long et al. 2004 study and more recent data from Henneman 2025 confirm this. Fourth, robustness against competing hypotheses: examiner cognitive bias does not predict discographic positivity. Non-specific pain modulation does not generate a directional treatment effect modifier. An antalgic position is neither rapid, nor reversible, nor reproducible in this manner. The hypothesis of a real phenomenon grounded in disc mechanics is the only one that survives confrontation with the full convergence of independent evidence. Fifth, current knowledge in disc biomechanics, biology, and pathology is consistent with the existence of a directional repeated movement effect as a modifier of disc condition..
This is not absolute proof. No clinical construct reaches that standard at this stage. It is, however, a structured, coherent, and defensible argument — what philosophers of science call inference to the best explanation. This is precisely how mature scientific disciplines build their theoretical entities: through the convergence of independent constraints, not through the accumulation of randomised trials conducted on poorly defined populations.
One condition remains essential for all of this to be meaningful: the definition of directional preference must be strict, unambiguous, and consistently applied. One hundred and eleven definitions for a single phenomenon is not conceptual richness — it is organised confusion. A rare sign that is precisely defined is worth infinitely more than a frequent sign that means different things to different people. It is on this condition that directional preference can claim the place it deserves — both in clinical practice and in the scientific literature.
References
[1] Kidd JA, Lorenzetti JM, Kirby KW, Young JL, Cleland JA, Schenk RJ. Identifying Directional Preference: A Scoping Review and Thematic Analysis of Variability and Application in Musculoskeletal Pain Research. Physical Therapy 2025;105:pzaf094. https://doi.org/10.1093/ptj/pzaf094.
[2] Almeida MO, Narciso Garcia A, Menezes Costa LC, Van Tulder MW, Lin C-WC, Machado LA. The McKenzie method for (sub)acute non-specific low back pain. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2023;2023. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009711.pub2.
[3] May S, Runge N, Aina A. Centralization and directional preference: An updated systematic review with synthesis of previous evidence. Musculoskeletal Science and Practice 2018;38:53–62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msksp.2018.09.006.
[4] May S, Aina A. Centralization and directional preference: A systematic review. Manual Therapy 2012;17:497–506. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.math.2012.05.003.
[5] Garcia AN, Costa L da CM, de Souza FS, de Almeida MO, Araujo AC, Hancock M, et al. Reliability of the Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy System in Patients With Spinal Pain: A Systematic Review. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2018;48:923–33. https://doi.org/10.2519/jospt.2018.7876.
[6] Donelson R, Aprill C, Medcalf R, Grant W. A Prospective Study of Centralization of Lumbar and Referred Pain: A Predictor of Symptomatic Discs and Anular Competence. Spine 1997;22:1115–22. https://doi.org/10.1097/00007632-199705150-00011.
[7] Young S, Aprill C, Laslett M. Correlation of clinical examination characteristics with three sources of chronic low back pain. The Spine Journal 2003;3:460–5. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1529-9430(03)00151-7.
[8] Laslett M, Öberg B, Aprill CN, McDonald B. Centralization as a predictor of provocation discography results in chronic low back pain, and the influence of disability and distress on diagnostic power. The Spine Journal 2005;5:370–80. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spinee.2004.11.007.
[9] Deneuville J-P, Laslett M, Cervantes A, Peterlongo S, Ounajim A, Artico R. Concurrent validity of the directional preference phenomenon compared to controlled lumbar discography: A supplementary analysis of a diagnostic accuracy study. Musculoskeletal Science and Practice 2025;80:103413. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msksp.2025.103413.
[10] Long A, Donelson R, Fung T. Does it Matter Which Exercise?: A Randomized Control Trial of Exercise for Low Back Pain. Spine 2004;29:2593–602. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.brs.0000146464.23007.2a.
[11] Hennemann V, Ziegelmann PK, Marcolino MAZ, Duncan BB. The McKenzie Method delivered by credentialed therapists for chronic low back pain with directional preference: systematic review with meta-analysis. Journal of Manual & Manipulative Therapy 2024:1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/10669817.2024.2408084.
